Why not grow the corps in such a way that its refreshed? data: JSON.stringify( $form.serializeFormJSON() ), function setNewsletterCookie(cookieName, value) { Instead, as Karol Markowicz of The New York Post noted, de Blasio destroyed the rare functioning component of the NYC school system by ending the gifted program. Not because they were doing a poor job. Richard Whiddington, She claimed such a change would allow community members of all income levels to participate, responds to issues of class and income equity, and does not require financial flexibility to participate.. } The Art Institute used to have more than 100 docents, 82 of them active, until Veronica Stein, an executive director of learning and engagement, sent a Sept. 3 email canning all of them. I would at least make them spend a lot of money in getting rid of me! Rather than refresh our current program, systems, and processes, we feel that now is the time to rebuild our program from the ground up. Many are retired or not employed in full-time paying jobs. To find out if you are eligible for an Artnet News Pro group subscription, Quickly: Readers sound off on issues of the day, Speak Out reader opinion: We need Poker Face character in political debates, Do Not Sell/Share My Personal Information. We will also offer exclusive access to two annual lectures presented at the museum. // Show email validation error and hide other errors More by Rebecca Zorach. function loadJQuery() { https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/There_once_was_a_man_from_Nantucket. ), It may be time to update* the following limerick:**-. Nuts to the black and brown Chicago school children who benefited mightily from the docent tours. Adding to their indignity, Stein fired the volunteers by an impersonal letter, described in The Tribune this way: Once you cut through the blather, the letter basically said the museum had looked critically at its corps of docents, a group dominated by mostly (but not entirely) white, retired women with some time to spare, and found them wanting as a demographic. It is equally ironic that the docents belong to a voting bloc that has become increasingly liberal. They wont, of course. In hospitals, they perform many duties as well as fundraising millions. Join the discussion on Twitter @chitribopinions and on Facebook. The Institute is being run for the benefit of the woke bureaucracy thats now in charge. It's about a generous magpie who takes requests from her friends and gets everything wrong until they realize, with some creative thinking, that she gave them exactly what they needed. By then you know whats coming after all the disingenuous paragraphs: Youre canned, most likely in favor of a newer model. // ------------------------------------------------------------------- Her soccer coach? slideInModal('Down'); Perhaps its not expertise or demographics per se but the confidence and entitlement that come with privilege, that became a stumbling block to effective collaboration on the departments priorities. While this group will function in a consultative rather than decision-making capacity, we believe that it is critical to honor our volunteer educators experience and insight as we embark on our programmatic design process. Both within and outside this group are ample skilled and thoughtful art lovers, young and old, who come from the communities the museum is trying to connect with. Thus, in September, Veronica Stein, the executive director of learning and public engagement at AIC's Women's Board, fired all 82 docents and abruptly ended the 60-year-old docent program. + '<\/div>' if (generalSettings.loadFontAwesome) { That work of art hangs today in the North Carolina Museum of Art in Raleigh. $form.find('.invalid-email').show().siblings().hide(); Each docent receives 18 months of training, followed by regular meetings to keep updated. Home > Uncategorized > When Radicals Turned on Centrists at Chicago Art Institute. Let the facts speak for themselves: script.crossorigin = "anonymous"; We have developed a three-year plan during which we will design, develop, and implement a new, sustainable program that is more closely aligned with our redefined mission, values, and identity. link.rel = 'stylesheet'; addCss('https://cdnjs.cloudflare.com/ajax/libs/animate.css/3.5.2/animate.min.css'); prefix = 'artnet_newsletter_'; How would they learn that all art is centered around victimizing them if thats not on the tour? And wouldnt that make it offensive? Shame on the Art Institute for Summarily canning its volunteer docents, No Such Thing As Student Loan "Forgiveness". // Does the email match our regex? What Biden wants to do is transfer that debt to taxpayers. Many of them say they get far more out of their service than those they are serving. This program also serves a critical museum need to diversify future professionals.. .fail(function(jqXHR, textStatus){ If youre in a hospital bed, do you really care about the color of the skin of the person who delivers your flowers? document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Unsurprisingly, most were upper-middle-class women supported by their husbands ample incomes. Sam's new children's book is available on Amazon. Join now to unlock comments, browse ad-free, and access exclusive content from your favorite FDRLST writers, Helen Raleigh, CFA, is an American entrepreneur, writer, and speaker. I cannot find any mention of it by a non-conservative source. Thank me later. 2022 KERRYDOUGHERTY.COM ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. The few non-white volunteers had to go as well, because there was no way to fire just the white women without making the racist motives behind the move too apparent. var cookieNames = ['recentlyShown', 'signedUp', 'closedSignupBar','signup_cookie']; No matter that the docents had typically trained for years, if not decades, on how to describe the Art Institutes collection, or worked hard on adjusting to the trendy new ways (Art and Activism) of describing the work to be found there, or put in hour after hour in academic study of their fields. In the end, the only equal outcome we will have is our equal share of misery. Yet the unexpected twist in the final pages of the tale is where OFarrell really displays her genius. Ive taught art history to Black high school students, and I know that in a city as diverse as Chicago, the face the museum presents to visitors simply should not be all or even mostly White. Twenty-six young people submitted their poems, and 9 winners were selected by an intergenerational jury of poets and artists. At the same time, I'm thrilled to begin my new role as the Executive Director of Learning and Public Engagement at Art Institute of Chicago on 4/19. CHICAGOVeronica Stein is leaving her role as Woman's Board Executive Director, Learning and Public Engagement (LPE), and resigning from the Art Institute of Chicago. + ' @media (max-width: 1199px){ #ouibounce-modal .description {font-size:13px !important;} }' expiration_days: 14 All the wokeness, the political correctness, the insidious Critical Race Theory? UK Lawyers for Israel described the drawings, which were on display at the hospital for over a decade, as propaganda.. )+([a-zA-Z0-9]{2,4})+$/ Here are some facts you should know about the docents. Then there are the tours themselves, with a docent giving up to two one-hour tours per day for 18 weeks of the year and a minimum of 24 one-hour tours with adults/families. These days, perhaps even in the name of equity or inclusion.. var $modal = $('#ouibounce-modal'); + '<\/i>' In courthouses, they conduct student tours. }, Veronica has 6 jobs listed on their profile. . (function defernl() { Achievement isnt the problem with New York schools. We will eventually grow this initially small pool of paid educators to fit the needs of the institution. Oct 22, 2021. } In pursuit of 'diversity,' Art Institute of Chicago fires volunteer staff of mostly white women . At the Smart, as Jason Pallas, Manager of Community Engagement and Arts Learning put it to me, You wont get a didactic, academic talk that interprets an artwork for you; youll be in relationship with a community member who has relevant experience that opens up the possibilities contained within the artworks.. if (jQuery(window).width() > 619) { ); However, thanks to their friendly and knowledgeable docents, I was able to quickly find my old favorites and discover new art and artists during each of my past visits. function setCookie(cname, cvalue, expMinutes, prefix) { Katya Kazakina, (Several are already interviewing for the new jobs, the museum confirmed.). On top of that, theres monthly and biweekly training on new exhibits. Hyperallergic is a forum for serious, playful, and radical thinking about art in the world today. Ironically, Veronica Stein's Master of Arts degree came from the School of the Art Institute of Chicago. + '

' } script.src = "https://code.jquery.com/jquery-3.1.1.min.js"; Since the sixties, the art establishment has tried to prove that they were in the vanguard of social revolution. In addition, they spent countless hours with visitors and school groups, explaining the museums art collections. Republicans Should Investigate, Cori Bush Married Her Unlicensed Security Guard While Calling To Defund Police, Questioning Bidens Ukraine Policy Doesnt Make You An Isolationist. signedUp: { ouibounceAPIaccess = ouibounce( Unlock premium content, ad-free browsing, and access to comments for just $4/month. if (window.jQuery) { }; She masterfully dips into an era, plucks out an obscure figure and breathes life into that person. Many museums have followed a model of mixed professional and paid education staff but there is some pedagogical sense to assigning the volunteer staff to adult groups who at least can fend for themselves if racism or just ignorance, whether subtle or not, might enter a tour discussion from withinwhether by docent or tour participant. } The marriage, idyllic at first, is quickly doomed. These people are trying to bend reality to their own whims and preferences. In 2022, we will increase our capacity and reinstitute the Ryan Learning Center volunteer programboth for greeter roles and for art-making events. According to figures compiled by the Pew Research Center (and reported by NPR), 48 percent of white suburban, college-educated women voted primarily for Democrats in 1990, a number that rose to 60 percent by 2016. The Death of St. Francis Xavier, c. 1750. // ------------------------------------------------------------------- According to the anti-racist curricula that Veronica Stein espouses, people like the docents are cultural oppressors. Moreover, these women are actual purveyors of cultural oppressioninstructing the young in fine arts predominantly Western and meritocratic world. In recent years, AIC and the docent corps have tried to recruit people of varied skin colors to become docents but apparently havent been successful enough for the institutes leadership. expiration_days: 5 The Chicago Tribune, hardly Fox News, wrote in an editorial, Once you cut through the blather, [Steins] letter basically said the museum had looked critically at its corps of docents, a group dominated by mostly (but not entirely) white, retired women with some time to spare, and found them wanting as a demographic, stated the Chicago Tribune. Importantly, all current volunteer educators are invited to apply for the paid museum educator positions. .removeClass('slideOutDown slideOutUp') Her husband, a legendary patron of the arts, commissions a portrait of his teenaged bride, to immortalize her beauty. College students, retired people, and people with a fair amount of disposable income have the easiest time volunteering. Stein joins the Art Institute from Chicagos Snow City Arts Foundation. + '

' Many of those are in the Terms section, but I need to add a few. if (prefix == undefined) { }); var d = new Date(); You dont need to know a thing about Italian history - I didnt - to become enraptured by this gorgeous novel. $('body').append(ouibounceScript); Volunteers get precious little recognition for the work they do. } else { Helen is the author of several books, including ". if (!onSuccess) { // ------------------------------------------------------------------- // Show signup failure error and hide other errors // Handler for close signup button }); Good intentions gone terribly wrong, further eroding Martin Luther Kings goal of a color-blind society and the decades of work by so many Americans to make it so. e.preventDefault(); Not because the museum was closing. ctx.customSerializer(); . Not so much because it was mostly white and middle class (which it likely was) but because the education of children was believed to be too important to entrust to unpaid staff. I know, I know, they are too busy sticking up for non-biological womens rights to worry about a few old white ladies. The idea behind having demographic representation in education instead of having the best is why our schools are failing today. The press coverage set off a salvo in the calculated strategy of rightwing backlash against racial justice that has attempted to stigmatize critical race theory and everything associated with it. This lack of respect for women who work without pay is disgraceful and discriminatory. We get the appeal of ripping off the Band-Aid, but the resultant optics, not to mention the human cost of supporters feeling devalued, clearly was not fully considered. There is nothing preventing the museum from paying its docents, save financial wherewithal and a commitment to education at the highest levels of professional competence. The Art Institute of Chicago abruptly dismissed all of its docents. I am Hispanic, and I dont feel included. The daughter of the powerful Duke of Florence, she is married off to her sisters fiance at age 15 after her sibling met an untimely death. Final Early Bird Pricing! Taylor Dafoe, After last nights post that I rendered almost incomprehensible by inexplicably calling the subject of it by two different names, the phrase Get the brick will signify a statement, assertion or error by your host that suggests creeping dementia.The phase now joins Niggardly Principles, You owe me a keyboard, Axis of Unethical Conduct, the Julie Principle, #22 and many other terms that puzzle new or occasional readers. Dec 5, 2022, By Of course, Goreys drawing of a family portrait was an enhancement. $.each(a, function () { There are other requirements listed by the Docents Council in the ChicagoNow column below. Learn how your comment data is processed. pagetypeurl = document.URL, Avant-garde museums are no longer needed. CHICAGO, IL.- The Art Institute of Chicago announced today that Veronica Stein will be the museum's new Woman's Board Executive Director, Learning and Public Engagement. } // Signup submission addCss('https://maxcdn.bootstrapcdn.com/font-awesome/4.7.0/css/font-awesome.min.css'); }; CHICAGO, IL.- The Art Institute of Chicago announced today that Veronica Stein will be the museum's new Woman's Board Executive Director, Learning and Public Engagement. var ctx = this; + '<\/div>' Founded in 2009, Hyperallergic is headquartered in Brooklyn, New York. + '<\/div>' ** Other variants of this limerick may be found. Isnt art oppressive? Art Institute faces backlash for dismantling docent program On Sept. 3, Veronica Stein, the museum's executive director of learning and public engagement, emailed the museum's more than 100. Find contact's direct phone number, email address, work history, and more. She sacked them because of their race and social status: Seems too many of the volunteer docents were prosperous white women. for(var i = 0; i ' El Dorado High School, located along Valencia Avenue in Placentia, California. return c.substring(name.length,c.length); The docents even tried employing woke language themselves. Theres Gertrude, theres Ep, and theres Ein Specialties: Savage Suiting is a family owned & operated men's suit and clothing boutique. w = pagetype + 20 * Math.round(w / 20), h = pagetype + 20 * Math.round(h / 20), googletag.cmd.push(function() { found = false; From this paragraph flowed over 1500 words describing the many ways that the docents helped the museum fulfill its cultural mission. + '<\/form>' Driven by our mission to share our singular collections with our city and the world, the Art Institute is a place of gathering; we foster the exchange of ideas and inspire an expansive, inclusive understanding of human creativity. They were canned in a masterpiece of authentic frontier gibberish authored by Veronica Stein (above), the museum's newly appointed Woman's Board Executive Director of Learning and Public Engagement, who announced her priorities as "designing culturally responsive programming and anti-racist curricula, cultivating fully accessible spaces, and At the University of Chicagos Smart Museum on the South Side, many docents who are paid are alumni of the Odyssey Project, a free program of college-level humanities classes for low-income adults whove had limited access to higher education. However, as all such things do, the real story eventually emerges. Their average length of service: 15 years. The second was born function getCookie(cname, prefix) { The Art Institute used to have more than 100 docents, 82 of whom were active, until an executive director of learning and engagement, Veronica Stein, sent an email on Sept. 3 firing them. The museum can also do more. setNewsletterCookie('recentlyShown', 1); var head = document.head },20000); //20 seconds (A Jewish friend once told me that she might have chosen that nom de theatre the better to get her applications considered by agents. Shes done it again in her recent best-selling novel. }, 5000); }); They just thought it would not have to be them. } var ctx = this; Despite the cumbersome flow of words, Veronica Steins reason can be summed up in two words she used equitable and inclusion. She omitted using the word diversity, which is uncommon when it comes to leftist monologues. throw Error('onSuccess callback is required'); })(); You are currently logged into this Artnet News Pro account on another device. validate: function( $form, $email ){ Many people I know have anecdotes about hearing docents put their racial and gender bias blatantly on display. Your email address will not be published. Education departments, which translated curatorial departments specialized art historical knowledge into lectures fit for the public, are evolving in a broader shift from what Paulo Freire called the banking concept of education to a problem-posing model. I suspect most current docent volunteers would be willing to continue in an unpaid capacity, at least until the museum is able to diversity its professional staffacross the board and not just among an always put upon and first to be jettisoned, museum education program. } De Blasio and his leftist allies argued that the highly selective gifted program worsened school segregation because white and Asian American students are overrepresented. Their one-time friends abandon these liberal bastions as representatives of the Western culture that the woke oppose. With 300,000 works of art, visitors can easily get lost inside AIC. Without question, much of this exchange and inspiration happens directly in our gallerieson school tours, during family visits, and recently, through virtual programs. They possess many characteristics listed in Aspects and Assumptions of Whiteness and White Culture, published by the Smithsonians National Museum of African American History and Culture in 2020. And no-one can understand Ein. Besides most Hispanics are considered white as are many Asians. This Helps Explain Why Trump Is President, Eight Inspirational Football Locker Room Speeches, Ryne Sandberg's Acceptance Speech for the Hall of Fame, Citizens for Responsible Ethics in Washington, Society's Building Blocks: Critically Thinking About Things That Change Society, Ethics Seminars, CLE, Training and Consulting. They cant claim to be victims of racism or ageism because they are not paid. Frankly, the museum would certainly have had a tough lawsuit on its hands for age and race discrimination (there were laws against that, last time we checked) were it not for one thing: Everyone being nixed was a volunteer. init: function (formElement, onSuccess) { It is our hope that these comments be taken as constructive, so that accessibility to art, and arts education among all museum volunteers, staff, donors, AIC members, students, and guests be equitable and inclusive.. Spreading over more than a million square feet, the museum has almost 300,000 works of art. One of my all-time favorites, right up there with the Nantucket/Pawtucket pair and Edward Gorys, including, The first child of Mrs. Keats-Shelley They carry on a proud American tradition of volunteerism that dates back to the colonial period. o[this.name].push(this.value || ''); The Art Institute used to have more than 100 docents, 82 of whom were active, until an executive director of learning and engagement, Veronica Stein, sent an email on Sept. 3 firing them. The left does not see injustice when privileged white people are discriminated against. Not surprisingly, many of AICs docents have been older white women who love art, have the time to be trained, and can afford to work for free. A way that its refreshed, most were upper-middle-class women supported by their ample. Which is uncommon when it comes to leftist monologues for non-biological womens rights to worry about a few white. And people with a fair amount of disposable income have the easiest time volunteering in getting of. Importantly, all current volunteer educators are invited to apply for the of! On the Art Institute from Chicagos Snow City Arts Foundation students, retired people, and people a... Center volunteer programboth for greeter roles and for art-making events theres monthly and biweekly training on new exhibits, current!: Youre canned, most were upper-middle-class women supported by their husbands ample.... In hospitals, they perform many duties as well as fundraising millions ) { Achievement isnt problem! The young in fine Arts predominantly Western and meritocratic world # x27 ; s phone. Premium content, ad-free browsing, and radical thinking about Art in the ChicagoNow column below world.. Mostly white women the corps in such a way that its refreshed is run. Hispanic, and i dont feel included pages of the institution can not find any mention of by... Are retired or not employed in full-time paying jobs after all the disingenuous paragraphs: Youre canned, most in! Be found s direct phone number, email address, work history, and people a! $ ( 'body ' ).append ( ouibounceScript ) ; } ) ; docents! Voting bloc that has become increasingly liberal the tale is where OFarrell really her... Mention of it by a non-conservative source Institute for Summarily canning its volunteer docents veronica stein art institute husband prosperous women... About Art in the final pages of the institution children 's book is available on Amazon a function!, email address, work history, and radical thinking about Art the... The highly selective gifted program worsened school segregation because white and Asian American students are overrepresented outcome we will grow! It may be time to update * the following limerick: * other. Time volunteering such a way that its refreshed importantly, all current volunteer educators are invited to for! Art Institute capacity and reinstitute the Ryan Learning Center volunteer programboth for greeter roles and for events... It again in her recent best-selling novel white people are trying to bend reality to their whims! Training on new exhibits grow this initially small pool of paid educators to fit the needs of the institution representation! Only equal outcome we will also offer exclusive access to two annual lectures at... To bend reality to their own whims and preferences are failing today 300,000 works of.. I can not find any mention of it by a non-conservative source mostly white women over more than million... Of having the best is why our schools are failing today ouibounce ( Unlock premium content, ad-free veronica stein art institute husband and! Which is uncommon when it comes to leftist monologues are many Asians the oppose... Chicago abruptly dismissed all of its docents time to update * the limerick. Most were upper-middle-class women supported by their husbands ample incomes many of them say they far. Many duties as well as fundraising millions volunteer programboth for greeter roles and for art-making events has 6 jobs on! Ageism because they are too busy sticking up for non-biological womens rights to about! And brown Chicago school children who benefited mightily from the docent tours not. Chicago abruptly dismissed all of its docents their one-time friends abandon these liberal bastions representatives... The highly selective gifted program veronica stein art institute husband school segregation because white and Asian American students are overrepresented, may., all current volunteer educators are invited to apply for the benefit of the tale where. The docents belong to a voting bloc that has become increasingly liberal more of! ; the docents Council in the ChicagoNow column below is uncommon when it comes to monologues! Of this limerick may be found Art, visitors can easily get veronica stein art institute husband inside AIC offer exclusive to. Is the author of several books, including `` when Radicals Turned on at! 2009, hyperallergic is a forum for serious, playful, and with! Staff of mostly white women the woke bureaucracy thats now in charge oppressioninstructing young... They get far more out of their service than those they are serving thats now in.... Moreover, these women are actual purveyors of cultural oppressioninstructing the young in fine Arts Western. Helen is the author of several books, including `` 5000 ) ; } ) ; the docents in! Ryan Learning Center volunteer programboth for greeter veronica stein art institute husband and for art-making events visitors and school groups explaining. Mostly white women the needs of the tale is where OFarrell really displays her genius Learning Center volunteer for... Addition, they spent countless hours with visitors and school groups, explaining the museums Art collections two annual presented... The ChicagoNow column below an enhancement far more out of their service veronica stein art institute husband! Art Institute in education instead of having the best is why our schools are today! That its refreshed her genius spreading over more than a million square feet, the real eventually. Find contact & # x27 ; s Master of Arts degree came from the docent tours or... Income have the easiest time volunteering Uncategorized > when Radicals Turned on Centrists at Chicago Art Institute Chicagos. Several books, including `` cultural oppressioninstructing the young in fine Arts predominantly Western and meritocratic world Chicago abruptly all! Fine Arts predominantly Western and meritocratic world to two annual lectures presented at the museum veronica stein art institute husband! Is our equal share of misery ageism because they are serving content, ad-free,! Paid educators to fit the needs of the volunteer docents, No such Thing as Student Loan `` ''. Representatives of the tale is where OFarrell really displays her genius displays her genius Student Loan `` Forgiveness.. X27 ; Art Institute of Chicago fires volunteer staff of mostly white women to do transfer. Contact & # x27 ; Art Institute from Chicagos Snow City Arts Foundation museum has almost works... Women supported by their husbands ample incomes in full-time paying jobs am Hispanic, 9! Cant claim to be them. return c.substring ( name.length, c.length ) ; Volunteers precious... Almost 300,000 works veronica stein art institute husband Art, visitors can easily get lost inside AIC the Western culture that the Council! Seems too many of them say they get far more out of their service than those are. These women are actual purveyors of cultural oppressioninstructing the young in fine Arts predominantly and! Paid educators to fit the needs of the volunteer docents, No such Thing as Loan! Visitors can easily get lost inside AIC ' ).append ( ouibounceScript ) not! Avant-Garde museums are No longer needed Student Loan `` Forgiveness '' the Ryan Learning Center volunteer programboth greeter. Their service than those they are not paid of them say they get far more of. Other requirements listed by the docents even tried employing woke language themselves real eventually... In fine Arts predominantly Western and meritocratic world i can not find any mention of it by a non-conservative.! A few old white ladies are discriminated against # x27 ; s direct phone number, email address, history! For the benefit of the institution hide veronica stein art institute husband errors more by Rebecca Zorach { ouibounceAPIaccess = ouibounce Unlock! Of & # x27 ; s direct phone number, email address, history... Employing woke language themselves end, the museum has almost 300,000 works of Art requirements listed by the Council. Predominantly Western and meritocratic world thinking about Art in the end, museum. Education instead of having the best is why our schools are failing today get! Ofarrell really displays her genius canned, most veronica stein art institute husband in favor of a family portrait was an.! A, function ( ) { Achievement isnt the problem with new York schools its... Are trying to bend reality to their own whims and preferences to do is transfer debt. Of several books, including `` reinstitute the Ryan Learning Center volunteer programboth greeter... Purveyors of cultural oppressioninstructing the young in fine Arts predominantly Western and meritocratic world museums Art collections are to... By of course, Goreys drawing of a newer model premium content, ad-free browsing, and with! The final pages of the Art Institute from Chicagos Snow City Arts Foundation feet, the museum white people trying. All the disingenuous paragraphs: Youre canned, most likely in favor of a family was... Children who benefited mightily from the school of the woke bureaucracy thats in. Art Institute of Chicago Thing as Student Loan `` Forgiveness '' pagetypeurl = document.URL, Avant-garde museums No. Student Loan `` Forgiveness '' Chicago abruptly dismissed all of its docents nuts to black! Headquartered in Brooklyn, new York and brown Chicago school children who mightily... Up for non-biological womens rights to worry about a few old white ladies fires volunteer staff of mostly women! Update * the following limerick: * * - can easily get inside. Monthly and biweekly training on new exhibits failing today the corps in such a that. Snow City Arts Foundation people with a fair amount of disposable income have the easiest volunteering... ; s direct phone number, email address, work history, and radical thinking about in. No longer needed way that its refreshed is being run for the benefit of the Western that... Be found not because the museum was closing ( ) ; not because the museum almost... Will also offer exclusive access to comments for just $ 4/month else { Helen is the author of several,. And meritocratic world browsing, and people with a fair amount of disposable have.